What exactly is Plumtickled? In summary: "Original 1882 general store in Dunfee, IN on the Whitley/Allen County Line Rd between State Rd 30 and State Rd 14, approx 7 miles from I-69. Specializing in primitives, antiques, old fashioned candy counter, USDA grass fed beef, assortment of Wisconsin cheese curds and cheese, farm fresh eggs, Amish butter and noodles, local honey, and a wide variety of specialty products. Also located within the Junction is Painted Pony Tack specializing in English tack, attire, gifts, and Pickles Cafe serving paninis and wraps, home made soups and desserts. Two Sisters Garden Barn with seasonal hours."
In short: Charmingly delicious.
Photos by Tony Frantz